Its work includes the recently completed National Memorial for

rejecting idea of apartments overhead

CLEVELAND, Ohio The Cleveland KnockOff Handbags Public Library, the Designer Fake Bags Cleveland Foundation and LAND Studio ran replica handbags china a spirited design competition for a Replica Bags Wholesale new Martin Luther King Jr. Branch that resulted in three strong choices unveiled last Thursday.

Fake Designer Bags Nevertheless, it’s clear that the concept offered by MASS Design Group of Boston, with LDA aaa replica designer handbags Architects, of Cleveland and other cheap replica handbags consultants, is the strongest choice. Fake Designer Bags

aaa replica designer handbags More than any other proposal, the MASS proposal best meets the most important selection criteria in the design funded by the Handbags Replica Cleveland Foundation and managed by LAND. aaa replica designer handbags

These include Wholesale Replica Bags providing ”an architecturally innovative and iconic design” replica Purse that honors the legacy of Martin Luther King and ”adds to University Circle’s reputation for excellent and architecturally varied and distinctive buildings.”

high quality replica handbags Ironically, the MASS design scores well on these points because it is the only one that rejects Replica Bags Wholesale another criterion: that Handbags Replica the new MLK branch would have an replica Purse apartment building erected over it as part of the upcoming, $300 million Circle Square development in University Circle. high quality replica handbags

The big development project, which could begin construction next summer, calls for four blocks of apartments, retail and parking between Chester and Euclid Avenues west of Stearns Road,

replica Purse The Request for Qualifications issued by the library last October to launch the library design competition states that Midwest Development Partners LLC agreed that before building the rest of its Replica Bags Wholesale project, it would first replace the existing MLK Branch at 1962 Replica Designer Handbags Stokes Blvd with a the new, $10 million library along Euclid Ave. just west of Stokes. replica Purse

Designer Replica Bags The library and the developer also agreed that apartments could be built in the air rights space wholesale replica designer handbags directly above the library, creating a hybrid building 5 to 10 stories in height. Designer Replica Bags

Wholesale Replica Bags The finalist teams comprised of SO IL of Brooklyn, New York, with architect Jonathan Kurtz of Cleveland, and Bialosky Architects of Cleveland with Vines Architecture of Raleigh, high quality replica handbags NC, Replica Designer Handbags followed the competition brief and showed Replica Bags Wholesale how an apartment tower whose design is not yet known purse replica handbags could fit atop Fake Handbags the library. Wholesale Replica Bags

Designer Fake Bags All three teams also came up with credible concepts for a library with Fake Designer Bags flexible, light filled interior spaces that could accommodate education, public events, high tech innovation and quiet learning. Designer Fake Bags

Replica Bags Wholesale The Bialosky proposal has the virtue of making eloquent use of daylight throughout its interior replica designer bags spaces, especially where light would pour down through penetrations in floor levels that would surround muscular ”super columns” designed to support the library and the replica handbags online apartments above. Replica Bags Wholesale

Handbags Replica The SO IL proposal took the bold step of reconceiving the library as an elevated ”table of brotherhood” inspired by imagery in King’s famous ”I have a dream speech.” Handbags Replica

Replica Designer Handbags The MASS team, however, was alone in its decision that the library and the apartment tower would be better if they were treated as separate but adjacent structures. Replica Designer Handbags

purse replica handbags By taking this position, the team is asking the Replica Bags library and Midwest Development Partners to reconsider whether apartments should surmount a library that would symbolically function as a memorial to one of America’s pivotal leaders on civil rights. purse replica handbags

That’s a Replica Handbags very good question to raise now.

Part of the reasoning behind the MASS proposal is the firm’s assertion is that the developer wouldn’t suffer economically if the apartment were treated as a separate building.

replica handbags online The designers suggest that Midwest development could make its apartment building 19 stories high instead wholesale replica designer handbags of 10 stories, thereby compensating for the Fake Designer Bags lost air rights development space directly over the library. The library’s board of trustees will make the ultimate purse replica handbags decision at a meeting aaa replica designer handbags on May 22. replica handbags online

Replica Handbags The developer will certainly have a say. Steve Rubin, a partner wholesale replica designer handbags at Midwest, said Friday that the firm is delighted by the results of the competition and is committed to wholesale replica designer handbags collaborating with the library and ”finding the best possible library that fits Replica Designer Handbags into the best possible development.” Replica Handbags

Fake Handbags He declined to Fake Handbags comment on any specific proposal. Fake Handbags

cheap replica handbags MASS brought to the library competition the firm’s widely known commitment to social justice. Its work includes the recently completed National Memorial for Peace and Justice Replica Designer Handbags in Montgomery, AL. cheap replica handbags

That facility includes an Replica Bags Wholesale open air cloister memorial to victims of lynching, with 800 weathered rectangular steel columns hanging from the roof. Each is etched with the names of victims and their home counties.

replica handbags china As a reporter from the New cheap replica handbags York Times noted, as you reach the memorial, ”the columns are all dangling above, leaving you in Replica Designer Handbags the position of the callous spectators in old photographs of public lynchings.” replica handbags china

wholesale replica designer handbags An equally vivid understanding of American history is evident in the MLK library proposal. wholesale replica designer handbags

MASS conceived of the building as a free standing replica Purse architectural form with a pleated skin of colored glass designed by artist Hank Willis Thomas Handbags Replica to evoke the coded messages in African American quilts used to send signals to slaves escaping from the South along stops on the Underground Railroad, including Cleveland.

Replica Bags The design calls for a library that could include an auditorium as well as a large, flexible space for community gatherings. It would also include an exterior staircase overlooking a plaza replica handbags china with a shallow reflecting pool, Wholesale Replica Bags trees and sculptures including portrait busts of community leaders. Replica Bags

KnockOff Handbags Any of the three proposals in the design competition would make a strong choice, and as Rubin, the developer, pointed out in his interview, all three raise functional and structural questions for Midwest development. KnockOff Handbags

But if coming up with an iconic statement about King and the history of civil rights in America is the key consideration, the library and Midwest ought to rethink whether apartments should be placed above the new library.